Variable HD TV

Last night I watched a pretty decent 1950 noir movie, The Damned Don’t Cry, which I recorded a little while ago from GEM. GEM is of course a HDTV station which means, here in Canberra, a 1,440 by 1,080 interlaced signal.

It looked really quite nice, with the dramatic black and white photography managing to be presented sharply, with not much noise. Good movie, too, except that Joan Crawford is way too old for the main character, and looks it.

Contrast this with an other GEM broadcast, a fairly gritty British war drama from the previous year, The Small Back Room. This is in large part about the bureaucratic mindset, even in the midst of war.

But my attention was constantly distracted by picture quality issues: specifically, there was visible combing as though it were being deinterlaced poorly. I’ve noticed this previously on mainly British 1940s and 1950s fare. I spent a fair bit of time fiddling with the deinterlacing controls on my home theatre receiver, to no avail. So I decided to examine it more closely in the computer.

Here’s a frame about a third of the way in, and underneath it is a detail from that frame, blown up to double the actual size:

The Small Back Room frame and detail

If you look at this closely, you will see that the image is actually interlaced at 1080i, but that is nothing that would cause any problems with modern video processing. What was more troubling were the remaining jaggies, as most clearly seen in the window frame to the right of the man’s head.

Now the camera was static at this point in the movie, so there can have been no mismatched between one field and the next due to movement. That’s why there’s no 1080i combing on them (while there clearly is on the back of the fellow’s head, since he is nodding at this point in the movie).

So what could that combing be?

A clue can be had by counting them. I counted twenty full cycles of combing in 75 vertical pixels in the image. Translated to 1080 pixels, that comes to 288 combing cycles, which is of course half of 576, which suggests that the video came from an interlaced source at 576 line resolution per frame, 288 per field.

So why the combing? I’d suggest that the film spent time on standard definition interlaced video with a slight misalignment between fields.

Not quite HDTV. Just upscaled, poor quality SDTV.

Fortunately, this is an example of the lower quality stuff on HDTV. But some of the content is, by contrast, really very good.

BTW: free to a good home (Australian mailing addresses only) Season One of the Australian TV drama ‘Crownies’ on Blu-ray. No boxes, test discs (there are four). Fact is, I haven’t been able to bring myself to watch them, and I doubt I ever will. First in comments gets ’em.

This entry was posted in HDTV. Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to Variable HD TV

  1. Tim Wainwright says:

    Hey there…. Either no one is reading, seeing as it’s Christmas, or maybe Crownies isn’t something that is all that interesting/good….

    Anyhow, I’ll take them off your hands if they’re still available. Drop me a line and I’ll email the address.

    Can’t wait for your take on The Hobbit in HFR…. Reading many conflicting reports, and can’t see it in Ballarat in HFR…. Have to go to Melbourne, which doesn’t interest me! Will catch the standard version here.

    Did you ever write up why the Aussie TV stations don’t do HD broadcasts on their main channels, or refuse to show mainstream new shows in HD. Forces one to consider alternative sources for most new shows unfortunately… Seems to me that they are doing themselves a disservice.


  2. Tim, email me your address (scdawson at for the discs, thanks.

    As for The Hobbit, I’ve got to say that Jackson spent a great deal of talent on magnificently realising fantasy action sequences which amount to essentially a boring story. The HFR definitely improved clarity.

    TV stations’ decisions are generally beyond my understanding I’m afraid. However at least until the analogue switch-off, I understand that they are required to replicate the analogue station in SD in digital.

    Now it’s probably too late to switch around to HD. Upset too many customers whose TVs/STBs won’t necessarily pick up the changes.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *