Se7en – the Blu-ray vs DVD comparison

Well, belatedly, here it is. And for a taste, here is one of the comparison shots:

Se7en Blu-ray vs DVD comparison

Posted in Blu-ray, Disc details, DVD | Leave a comment

The African Queen Blu-ray vs DVD comparison

It’s right here. Pretty nice job by Beyond Home Entertainment.

Here’s a sample:

African Queen comparison

Posted in Blu-ray, Disc details, DVD | 2 Comments

Actual Blu-ray 3D content coming!

Roadshow has just announced that on 30 December it will be releasing Piranha 3D on Blu-ray 3D, followed by Cats & Dogs 2: The Revenge of Kitty Galore as a two disc release with Blu-ray 3D on one and the regular 2D version on the other. This will appear on 7 January 2011.

Update (11 Dec): Fixed title (ie. ‘comment’ to ‘content’. Do’h!)

Posted in 3D, Blu-ray | 1 Comment

World’s Weirdest Blu-ray mastering job?

Or, how Evan Almighty wastes 13,324,032,000 bytes on nothing useful at all.

Posted in Blu-ray, Disc details | Leave a comment

Adding colour

Well, Australia collapsed today in the cricket, losing badly to England. I didn’t realise this until I switched on the system to find ‘Gilligan’s Island’ showing instead.

And, wow, how awful was the picture from ‘Gilligan’s Island’? Okay, the particular episode dates from 1965, so you can’t expect too much. But this was too much: incredibly soft, and with this slightly weird colour, with too frequent off-colour fringes on the edges of characters; eg. see Thurston Howell III’s chin, nose and forehead (cropped, not scaled):

Gilligan's Island capture

Then the reason became clear. Here is one of the end title plates:

Gilligan's Island credit

Turns out this episode was made in black and white, and then colourised in 1991. Pretty horrible job they did of it. I imagine that better results would be available today.

Posted in DTV | 5 Comments

Toy Story 3 – Blu-ray vs DVD comparison

Well, belatedly, here it is. As I mentioned earlier, the DVD proved to be a challenge in frame grabbling, thanks to Disney’s intentional corruption of its structure in order to make disc copying a smidge more difficult. This was complicated by the fact that the main version of the movie on Blu-ray was constituted by a chain of 46 individual files (the disc caters for other on-screen languages in various places and uses seamless branching to achieve this). This made for logistical problems in extracting suitable frames.

So in the end, instead of a scattering of frames from the whole movie, I selected them all from one segment of no more than about twenty minutes. Anyway, go to the comparison here, and here is a sample:

Posted in Blu-ray, Disc details, DVD | Leave a comment

Wiki vandal

I agree with the sentiment, if not the means of conveying it. For a few minutes this was at the end of the introduction in Wikipedia’s article on the Channel Nine Network here in Australia:

The Nine Network is probably best known as the leading equal opportunity broadcaster in Australia after they became the first station to employ a robot – Karl Stefanovic. As well as this they are known as the broadcaster that has made the worst decision since the Trojan army took a liking to a wooden horse by deciding to show the Ashes 2010 series in standard definition. Possibly to make room for glorious 4:3 aspect ratio repeats of Friends.

I grabbed that about 3:43pm today. By 3:48pm it had been undone.

Here’s a screen shot. Right click and download to see the detail:

Nine sadly attacked

(h/t to Tweet by Scott Fitzgerald).

Posted in Computer | 3 Comments

Imagining colour

On the most recent Skeptic’s Guide to the Universe podcast the normal ‘Science or Fiction’ segment was run by Richard Saunders, the famous Australian skeptic, known for amongst other things The Skeptic Zone podcast. His first science or fiction question was:

Although Mainstream professional television was launched in Australia in 1956, it was not until 1975 that Australian TV networks switched from broadcasting in B/W to colour.

This reminded me of an early episode of home entertainment wishful thinking on my own part. If you haven’t listened to the episode yet, well to spoil this part of the show, this claim in correct. Colour television was highly anticipated in Australia. My own parents got in early and spent a fast sum of money on a 26 inch colour set, in advance of the official switch on.

As it happened, trials were being conducted, but we didn’t know on which programs the trials were being conducted. No web in those days of course.

I remember us gathered around the TV one day, peering at a TV show, and wondering whether it was in colour or not. We bumped up the ‘Colour’ control (basically, the saturation control) to its max, and sure enough there were some low level but perceptible colours on the screen. They were random, swirling noise, to be sure, but they were colour.

Still we weren’t sure.

Of course, all we really needed to do was drag our gaze from the TV for a moment and look at the real world, note what real colour looks like, then look back at the TV!

Happily, things were resolved within a day or so. With the colour control still maxed out, one morning Sesame Street came on. That really was in colour — bright, powerful and horribly oversaturated colour, thanks to the setting of the control. We bumped it rapidly back down to something sensible, and that soon put it all in perspective.

Posted in Mysticism, Video | 2 Comments

Silly audiophile claims … 2

Once I went into a hifi shop, which shall remain nameless. The owner was one of those who believed analogue to be clearly superior to digital. The same shop, at another time, insisted that a high quality composite video cable connection from a DVD player gave better picture quality than a mediocre (but functional) S-Video one.

To prove the analogue vs digital point, the owner played me a CD and then an LP, and there was no doubt about it: the sound from the LP was cleaner, far more coherent, and simply beautiful.

But the test was crap on so many levels. First, the CD and LP were played on different systems: different amps and speakers, not just sources. Second, the CD and the LP didn’t have the same version of the music on them, didn’t even have the same music on them, in fact, didn’t have anything vaguely comparable on them. The CD was a recording of a large scale orchestral work, a massively busy one, and there was little ability I felt to pick out the individual parts or instruments. It just collapsed into a buzzy mess.

The LP was a solo piano work, beautifully recorded.

After the test I agreed that the LP sounded much nicer than the CD, but demurred on the point that it had anything to say about the formats.

Then I noticed something. The LP’s label was Denon, and there’s something special about Denon recordings. I flipped the LP’s jacket over and — why yes! — this also was a digital recording! It’s just that final consumer delivery was on vinyl.

Posted in Analogue, Audio, Mysticism, Rant | 3 Comments

Have I mentioned I’m on twitter?

If not — or even if I have — you can follow me here: http://twitter.com/#!/stephencdawson

Posted in Admin | Leave a comment